England vs Croatia World Cup 2026: Can Tuchel's Three Lions Banish the 2018 Ghost? — Group L Preview, Lineups & 60 Years of Hurt

-- reading  |  Updated:

Match Report — England 4-2 Croatia: The Penalty Retake That Defined the Day

The match's defining moment came in the 12th minute. Noni Madueke drew a foul from Luka Modric in the box and the referee pointed to the spot. Harry Kane — who had infamously missed a penalty against France in the 2022 quarter-final — stepped up. Goalkeeper Dominik Livaković dived to his left and saved it. The England bench's hearts sank. But the referee was already signaling for a review: Josko Gvardiol had encroached into the penalty area before the kick was taken. Retake awarded.

Kane shot into the same corner. This time it went in. England 1-0, and the relief on Kane's face was visible from the upper deck of AT&T Stadium.

Croatia did not fold. In the 36th minute, Martin Baturina — the 23-year-old Dinamo Zagreb midfielder — unleashed a stunning long-range strike that gave Jordan Pickford no chance. 1-1. England responded before halftime: Kane rose above his marker to head home a pinpoint Declan Rice corner in the 42nd minute. 2-1. Then, in the fifth minute of first-half stoppage time, Petar Musa finished off a well-worked Croatian move to make it 2-2 at the break. Four goals. Forty-five minutes. Total chaos.

The second half belonged entirely to England. Jude Bellingham collected the ball on the right flank just two minutes after the restart, drove infield past two defenders, and curled a brilliant finish in off the post. 3-2. England controlled the remainder of the match, and substitute Marcus Rashford — on for the tiring Anthony Gordon — added the gloss with a low, curling strike from the edge of the box in the 85th minute. Final score: England 4-2 Croatia.

Kane Equals Lineker's Record — 10 World Cup Goals

Harry Kane's brace took his career World Cup goal tally to 10 — equalling Gary Lineker's long-standing England record. Kane needs just one more goal to become England's outright all-time World Cup top scorer. Given England have at least two more group matches and potentially five more if they reach the final, breaking Lineker's record appears highly likely before this tournament ends.

The 2018 Ghost — Finally Banished

Eight years ago in Moscow, Croatia beat England 2-1 in extra time in the World Cup semi-final — Kieran Trippier's early free kick undone by Ivan Perišić and Mario Mandžukić. That defeat has haunted English football for nearly a decade. Today, in Dallas, with a different generation of players but the same two nations on the same World Cup stage, England finally got their revenge. It will not erase 2018 from history, but it gives this England generation something the 2018 squad never had against Croatia: a win when it mattered.

Tuchel's Halftime Message — "Be Brave"

Thomas Tuchel revealed after the match that his halftime instructions were simple and direct: "I wanted them to do it our way, be brave, courageous, intense and on the front foot and just go for it." Whatever he said clearly worked — England were transformed after the break, dominating territory and chances in a way that contrasted sharply with the nervous, error-strewn first half. Tuchel later admitted: "I think we showed a bit of nerves." The response to those nerves was the story of the second half.

🎯 Micro Angle 1: The 2018 Ghost — Croatia Beat England Before

The 2018 World Cup semi-final in Moscow is the defining painful memory of modern English football. Kieran Trippier scored a stunning free kick in the 5th minute. England were in a World Cup final. Then Ivan Perisic equalized in the second half. Then Mario Mandzukic won it in extra time. Croatia were in the final, England were going home, and yet another generation of English supporters added a new wound to 52 years of hurt that has since become 60.

Every England supporter watching today will have that semi-final somewhere in their head. Trippier, who is now 35 and starting at left back rather than right back, will feel its specific weight. The Croatian players know exactly what they represent to England's football psyche. Modric, who orchestrated that 2018 victory in Moscow, takes to the field in Dallas today at 40 years old. The specific symmetry of this fixture — same two teams, same tournament stage, 8 years on — is not lost on anyone involved.

🎯 Micro Angle 2: Harry Kane — World Cup Goals Record in His Own Right

Harry Kane is England's all-time top scorer and one of the most clinical penalty-box forwards of his generation. He has 8 World Cup goals across 2018 and 2022 — the joint-highest among active players from UEFA nations behind Kylian Mbappe (14). Kane arrives at this World Cup in the form of his career: Bayern Munich's Bundesliga top scorer for a second consecutive season, 40 goals in all competitions in 2025-26. He has averaged more than a goal per game for his country when fit. Against Croatia's centre-back pairing of Dario Spikic and Josko Gvardiol, both extremely good, he will still be the most dangerous penalty-box forward on the pitch.

🎯 Micro Angle 3: Jude Bellingham — The Player England Built the Team Around

Jude Bellingham is 22 years old. He plays for Real Madrid. He has won the Champions League, two La Liga titles, and was the Champions League Player of the Season in 2024-25. He operates as the deep-lying creative force in Tuchel's 4-3-3 — a position that is neither exactly the No.8 nor the No.10, but a role built specifically around his ability to receive in tight spaces, turn, and distribute or drive forward. When Bellingham is at his best for England — which he was throughout their qualification campaign, scoring 9 goals in 8 matches — England are capable of beating anyone.

The question that has followed Bellingham his entire international career: does his extraordinary club form translate consistently at tournament level? Euro 2024 gave mixed evidence. The World Cup 2026 starts today.

🎯 Micro Angle 4: Thomas Tuchel — The German Manager Leading England

Thomas Tuchel is German. He managed Chelsea, Paris Saint-Germain and Bayern Munich before taking the England job in January 2025. The Football Association's decision to appoint a foreign manager was controversial — the last foreign England manager, Sven-Göran Eriksson, reached the quarter-finals twice but never the semi-final. Fabio Capello and Steve McClaren also preceded Gareth Southgate, who in three tournaments reached one final and two semi-finals.

Tuchel's qualification campaign was flawless: eight wins from eight, zero goals conceded. England scored 30 goals in those eight matches. The pattern was attacking, direct, high-press, Bellingham-Saka axis creating and Kane converting. Whether that translates to the heat and pressure of a World Cup knockout environment, where the opposition quality is vastly higher, is the central question of England's 2026 tournament.

🎯 Micro Angle 5: Luka Modric's Farewell — 40 Years Old, Last World Cup

Luka Modric is 40 years old. Every major tournament of the past six years has been described as his "last" and he has kept proving that wrong. He won the Ballon d'Or in 2018 — the only player not named Messi or Ronaldo to win the award in 20 years. He is still at Real Madrid, still playing regularly in La Liga, still technically the finest midfielder in Croatia's history by a distance that no successor has remotely closed. Against England's midfield of Bellingham, Rice and Gallagher, Modric will face a much younger, more physical opposition than anything he encountered in 2018. Whether his football intelligence can compensate for the physical decline that inevitably comes at 40 is the tactical question of this match.

Expected Lineups

The Context — England's 60 Years of Hurt

England have won one major international trophy in their history: the 1966 World Cup, on home soil, against West Germany. That is 60 years ago. In the decades since, England have been eliminated by Argentina in 1986 and 1998, lost to Germany on penalties in 1990 and 1996, been beaten by Croatia in 2018, lost to Italy on penalties in the Euro 2020 final on home soil, lost to France in the 2022 World Cup quarter-final, and lost to Spain in the Euro 2024 final. The gap between England's talent and their tournament results has defined English football for three generations.

The squad Thomas Tuchel has assembled is arguably the most talented England group since 2002. Kane at his peak. Bellingham already a Champions League winner at 22. Saka — Arsenal's creative force — arguably the most dangerous right-winger in European football this past season. Alexander-Arnold revolutionizing what an attacking right back means. The talent is there. The question is whether, when the knockout rounds come and the pressure becomes genuinely crushing, England can do something different from every English team before them.